[Date Prev][Date Next] [Chronological] [Thread] [Top]

Re: ModifyDN -- subtrees or not?



Doing a subtree move operation is not always trivial, and even when it's possible it may not be very efficient. In my testing it appears that this is not supported by many/most LDAP server implementations. I think it would be good to explicitly identify the requirement level (MUST, SHOULD, MAY) for the sub-tree movement part of this operation.
 
Roger Harrison

>>> "Slone, Skip" <skip.slone@lmco.com> 08/22/01 11:57AM >>>
An issue has recently come up in the Directory Interoperability Forum
concerning what RFC 2251 really says on the matter of using ModifyDN to move
subtrees. As I read it, there's no clear conformance statement (a la RFC
2119) one way or another. The entire discussion in paragraph 4.9 is in plain
English (with no use of RFC 2119 keywords such as MUST). On that topic,
draft-ietf-ldapbis-protocol-02.txt is no clearer.

It seems to me this is an issue that needs clarifying. Any thoughts?

-- Skip Slone